スキップしてメイン コンテンツに移動

「静かな退職(Qiet Quitter) 」くたばれ!

 ネットに「静かな退職」という言葉が散見される。読むと、アメリカ発の言葉で、我がCOPILOTによれば、「Quiet Quittingとは、会社を辞めずに必要最低限の業務だけを行い、仕事と私生活の境界を明確にする働き方です。」と。俺の知ってる40年前のアメリカ人は、熱心なカトリックなら「働くなんて必要悪」と言ってたし、カトリックでなくても「早く金貯めて早くリタイアしたい」だった。アメリカ人は「一日も早く働くのを辞めたい」と公言していたし、もちろん1ドルでも自分を高く買ってくれる会社があれば転職した。つまり、ほとんど全員quiet quitterだった。だから、今更アメリカで何を言い出したんだ、と思う。

顧みれば日本だって、俺たちの世代は、入社の時は「同期の中で誰かが社長になるかも…」などと思ったが、10年20年と時間がたてば出世に差がつき、社長なんてなれるわけない、と分って来る、そして失われた〇〇十年に突入して会社は終身雇用の黙契を破り首切りを始め・・・それでも会社を辞める奴は少なかった・・・これって正しくQuiet Quitting。

それをネットでは、さも「新しいリスクだから、防止しなければならない」みたいに取り扱われている。本当に日本のコンサルもオールドだ。「アメリカでは・・・」と出羽守。続けて、さあ、私に相談しなさい・・・馬鹿か!

それじゃあ、御本家のアメリカじゃあ、どうなってる?と暇に任せてネットを当たると、

Investopaに以下。面白い部分のみ黄色でハイライト。

①まず、しょっぱなからTrend or Misnomer?だ。Misomerって「言い間違い」のことだ。つまり、Quiet Quittingなんて昔から当たり前にあるよ、「今更何言ってんの」かもね?だ。やっぱりアメリカじゃあ、わざわざquiet quittingなんて言うな、と考える人も多い。

② doubt its prevalence and whether it's really new.(別段新しいものじゃあない、昔からある現象に新しい名前を付けただけではないか?)

quiet firingmaking a job so unrewarding that a worker will feel compelled to quit.(つまんない仕事を与え、冷遇して退職を考えさせるように仕向ける・・・quiet firingというのもある。)→冷遇しても会社にしがみついて辞めない人もいるけど。そうなると、日本ではクビにしにくい。

④Quiet quitting has moved past the workplace to personal relationships, such as marriages.別に仕事だけじゃなく、仮面夫婦も同じだ・・・ってことは少しはアメリカ人も我慢するようになって嫌になっても離婚しない夫婦がいるってこと?

made replacing quiet quitters difficult, at least temporarily. Others responded to quiet quitting by quietly, or loudly, firing employees whom they saw as slacking off.上司の反応は2つに分かれる・・・①労働市場が売り手市場で首にできないので見て見ぬふりする②たるんでる、と首にする

ギャロップの調査では、アメリカの労働者の32%がやる気あり、18%はやる気なし。そのことを隠そうとしない・・・50%はquiet quitterで、そのことを特別大きな声で言おうともしない。

burned-out workers need new words to express their feelings.燃え尽き症候群の言い換えじゃあないか?という説もある

 あるアシスタントの言葉"I do not interact with anything from work before 7:00 or after 4:30,

これは昔からある典型的な”9-5”のOL。日本にもいる。「明日でいい仕事は明日に」・・・こんなの別にQuiet Quitterじゃない。

A department manager identified as Sara M. told NPR that her priorities and values had changed since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic: "I now leave my office at the end of the day not thinking about what I need to work on when I go home at night. I set boundaries for checking my emails and reaching out to co-workers during non-office hours. Most importantly, I do not feel any bit of anxiety when it comes to requesting time off, taking personal days, or especially taking sick time."ある課長の言葉:コロナの後、価値観が変わった。コロナ前は家に帰っても仕事してたし、時間外に同僚に連絡するなんてこともあった。コロナ前は休暇を取って仕事は大丈夫かなんて不安だったが、今はそんなことはない・・・この人、燃え尽き症候群ぽかったんじゃあないか?

"Resenteeism" がZ世代に特に流行ってる。仕事が嫌いなのに喰うためにやむなく働くというもの。Z世代に限らず、いやいや就職して働くというヤツがほとんどだ。(「働くのが嫌だから働かない」なんて脳天気を言ってられるのはごく一部だ)・・・少なくともかつて日本人は自分に向いてるかなんて考えずに与えられたポジションで与えられた仕事に真面目にいそしんだ。2,3年たつとそれで結構仕事が面白くなった。

quiet quittingが新しいトレンドなのか単なる言い換えなのかはともかく、2022年のギャロップ調査によれば、アメリカの労働者の半分以上に仕事への不満が広がっている・・・報酬的にもまた精神的にも、「やりがいのある仕事」がなくなった・・・この絶望・危機感に対し民主党は無反応だった。それでアメリカ人はトランプに一縷の望みをかけた。

<<以下抜粋>>

Understanding Quiet Quitting: Trend or Misnomer?

Quiet Quitting
Origins of the term have been credited to Nashville career coach Bryan Creely, economist Mark Bolger, or China's "lying flat" trend.

Laura Porter / Investopedia

Definition

Quiet quitting involves meeting only the basic expectations of a job without engaging in additional tasks or seeking advancement opportunities.


Key Takeaways

  • Quiet quitting involves meeting only the minimum job requirements without extra effort or enthusiasm.
  • The term gained popularity in the early 2020s, but some question whether it's new or just rebranded dissatisfaction.
  • A 2023 Gallup report indicated that 59% of the global workforce may be quiet quitters.
  • Critics argue engagement levels haven't changed much over the years, suggesting quiet quitting might not be a new trend.
  • Quiet quitting has expanded beyond the workplace, appearing in personal relationships and other areas of life.

What Is Quiet Quitting?

Quiet quitting is a workplace behavior where employees only do the bare minimum at their jobs. In the early 2020s, quiet quitting gained attention as a trend, mainly due to social media. Some, though, doubt its prevalence and whether it's really new.(別段新しいものじゃあない、昔からある現象に新しい名前を付けただけではないか?)

Data on the behavior includes Gallup's 2023 "State of the Global Workplace" report, which stated that 59% of the global workforce consisted of quiet quitters.1

Managers have had varied reactions, either tolerating the phenomenon or firing employees they thought were not putting in more effort, enthusiasm, and time than absolutely necessary. It has also led to related terms such as quiet firingmaking a job so unrewarding that a worker will feel compelled to quit.(つまんない仕事を与え、冷遇して退職を考えさせるように仕向ける・・・quiet firingというのもある。)

Quiet quitting has moved past the workplace to personal relationships, such as marriages.別に仕事だけじゃなく、仮面夫婦みたいな結婚も同じだよね。

Understanding the Dynamics of Quiet Quitting

In a September 2022 Harvard Business Review article aimed at explaining the quiet quitting phenomenon to worried executives, professors AnthonyC. Klotz and Mark C. Bolino observed, "Quiet quitters continue to fulfill their primary responsibilities, but they're less willing to engage in activities known as citizenship behaviors: no more staying late, showing up early, or attending non-mandatory meetings."2

The reaction of managers to the phenomenon has been mixed. Some have been tolerant, in part because the tight labor market of recent years made replacing quiet quitters difficult, at least temporarily. Others responded to quiet quitting by quietly, or loudly, firing employees whom they saw as slacking off. In fact, quiet firing has become a buzz phrase in its own right, generally defined as making a job so unrewarding that the employee will feel compelled to resign.3

上司の反応は2つに分かれる・・・①労働市場が売り手市場だから首にできないから見て見ぬふり②たるんでる、と首にする

Beyond the workplace, the term "quiet quitting" is now being applied to nonwork aspects of people's lives, such as marriages and other relationships. 

Origins of the Term "Quiet Quitting"

The Los Angeles Times credits Bryan Creely, a Nashville corporate recruiter turned career coach, with coining "quiet quitting" in a March 4, 2022, TikTok and YouTube video.4Some credit economist Mark Bolger with inventing "quiet quitting" in 2009. Others link the concept to China's "lying flat" trend from a year earlier.

56

Evaluating Quiet Quitting as a Workplace Trend

According to a Gallup survey of workers age 18 and older taken in June 2022, quiet quitters "make up at least 50% of the U.S. workforce—probably more." In Gallup's "State of the Global Workplace 2023 Report," 59% of the global workforce were said to be quiet quitters.71

In the United States, the percentage was particularly high among workers under age 35, Gallup reported.7

For its 2022 survey, Gallup arrived at that conclusion using a series of questions related to worker engagement, defined as "the involvement and enthusiasm of employees in their work and workplace."8

In the survey, only 32% of workers came across as engaged, while another 18% were disengaged, meaning that they made no secret of their job dissatisfaction. The remaining 50%, Gallup theorized, could be classified as quiet quitters—people who were not especially engaged in their work but didn't broadcast the fact.ギャロップの調査では、アメリカの労働者の32%がやる気あり、18%はやる気なし。そのことを隠そうとしない・・・50%はquet quitterで、そのことを特別大きな声で言おうともしない。

If accurate, these numbers suggest 68% of American workers are unhappy to some extent.

Not everyone buys that, however. Writing in The Atlantic, Derek Thompson pointed out that Gallup's 2022 engagement numbers weren't all that different from those going back to 2000. Thompson claims the term is popular because burned-out workers need new words to express their feelings.


燃え尽き症候群の言い換えじゃあないか?という説もある

Real-Life Instances of Quiet Quitting

NPR asked its listeners about quiet quitting and ran a group of their responses in a September 2022 online article. Some didn't like the term but still embraced the concept.10

An administrative assistant identified as Christy G. said, in part, "I do not interact with anything from work before 7:00 or after 4:30, which is the time my office is open. I work in a corporate setting so my tasks are not life or death. If someone asks for something, like maybe a file scanned or something like that, at the end of the day, it can wait until the next day."10


これは昔からある典型的な”9-5”のOL。日本にもいる。「明日でい仕事は明日に」・・・別にQuiet Quitterじゃない。

A department manager identified as Sara M. told NPR that her priorities and values had changed since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic: "I now leave my office at the end of the day not thinking about what I need to work on when I go home at night. I set boundaries for checking my emails and reaching out to co-workers during non-office hours. Most importantly, I do not feel any bit of anxiety when it comes to requesting time off, taking personal days, or especially taking sick time."10

ある課長の言葉:コロナの後、価値観が変わった。コロナ前は家に帰っても仕事してたし、時間外に同僚に連絡するなんてこともあった。コロナ前は休暇を取って仕事は大丈夫かなんて不安だったが、今はそんなことはない・・・この人、燃え尽き症候群ぽかったんじゃあないか?

How Many People Are Quiet Quitters?

If Gallup's estimate that at least 50% of the U.S. workforce can be classified as quiet quitters is accurate, then the number would be more than 85 million, according to the most recent U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data on Americans' employment status.711

 What Can Businesses Do About Quiet Quitting?

Some experts have suggested that bosses get tough, others that they lighten up. In an August 2022 Harvard Business Review article, leadership development consultants Jack Zenger and Joseph Folkman advised managers to first examine their own behavior. "Suppose you have multiple employees who you believe to be quietly quitting," they wrote. "In that case, an excellent question to ask yourself is: Is this a problem with my direct reports, or is this a problem with me and my leadership abilities?"12

What Is 'Soft Quitting’?

"Soft quitting" is a term that's often used interchangeably with quiet quitting.

What Is 'Resenteeism'?

"Resenteeism" is another purported workplace trend, in which employees, particularly members of Gen Z, stay in jobs that they supposedly resent. It is sometimes represented as a new and more advanced stage of quiet quitting, describing workers who aren't merely apathetic about their jobs but actively dislike them.13



Z世代に限らず、いやいや就職して働くヤツがほとんどだ。(「働くのが嫌だから働かない」なんて脳天気を言ってられるのはごく一部だ)・・・少なくともかつて日本人は自分に向いてるかなんて考えずに与えられたポジションで与えられた仕事に真面目にいそしんだ。2,3年たつとそれで結構仕事が面白くなった。

The Bottom Line

Quiet quitting is doing only the minimum requirements of a job without extra effort, enthusiasm, or time. A Gallup report from 2023 states that 59% of the global workforce consists of quiet quitters, underlining the potential prevalence of the phenomenon. Managers have had mixed reactions to quiet quitting, with quiet firing being one of their response tactics.

Debate continues over whether quiet quitting is a new trend or a rebranded name for existing employee dissatisfaction. Whatever you call it, insights from Gallup surveys—including a 2022 finding that quiet quitters comprise at least half, and "probably more" of the U.S. workforce—have called attention to what appears to be fairly widespread dissatisfaction among American workers.

quiet quittingが新しいトレンドなのか単なる言い換えなのかはともかく、2022年のギャロップ調査によれば、アメリカの労働者の半分以上に仕事への不満が広がっている

コメント

このブログの人気の投稿

”関口宏の一番新しい近現代史”を見る

長嶋追悼:広岡さん

IQ188という記録で注目を浴びた太田三砂貴(おおた・みさき)さん